notes on old shooters, kept mostly for myself

A month of playing keyboard-only

2026-06-28 · experiments

The original control scheme had no mouselook. You turned with the arrow keys, you could not aim up or down, and the game auto-aimed vertically for you. Everybody I know switches mouselook on immediately. I turned it off for four weeks to see what the design actually assumed.

Week one was miserable

Turning with a key is slow and it has a fixed speed. An enemy that walks around you is genuinely harder to deal with, and I died a lot in the first few evenings to things I would have flicked onto instantly with a mouse.

The first real change was that I stopped standing still. With slow turning, the correct answer to something approaching from the side is to reposition so that everything is in front of you, which means constant movement, which is exactly how these games look when you watch someone good play them.

Player circling a group of enemies in an open room
Strafing around the outside of a room instead of turning to face things one at a time.

What it changed about the maps

Here is the part I did not expect. Without vertical aim, height stops being a shooting problem and becomes purely a navigation problem. A sniper on a ledge is not a target — it is a hazard you route around until you find the stairs.

And the maps are built for that. Enemies placed above you are almost always placed to push you somewhere, not to be duelled. With mouselook I had been solving those encounters the wrong way for years, by simply looking up and shooting, and the map's intended pressure never applied.

Half of what I thought was clumsy design turned out to be design for a control scheme I had turned off.

The auto-aim is doing you a favour

The vertical auto-aim gets mocked, but playing this way makes its purpose obvious: it removes an axis of precision so the designer can rely on the horizontal one. Every encounter is composed in plan view. Once you stop fighting that, the fights read very differently — more like a board with positions than like a shooting gallery.

Automap view of a level showing loops and connections
Looking at the same level in plan view. The loops are the encounter design.

Would I keep it

Partly. I went back to mouselook for newer maps, because most community levels made in the last twenty years are built assuming you have it. For the original episodes I now leave it off, and they are better that way — harder in the first hour and more coherent after that.

If you try one thing from this post, try a single episode with mouselook off and the auto-aim on. Four or five maps is enough to feel the difference.

← all posts