notes on old shooters, kept mostly for myself

The sound is doing half the work

2026-07-19 · notes

I played an hour with the sound muted, not as an experiment but because someone was asleep in the next room. It turned into an experiment anyway, because the game got noticeably easier and noticeably less interesting at the same time.

Sound as information

These engines had no minimap, no enemy indicator, no directional damage marker. Everything you know about what is behind you, you know because you heard it. A door opening somewhere out of sight means something is coming. A particular grunt means a particular enemy, which tells you how much space you need.

With the sound off, all of that goes away and you compensate by turning around constantly. It works, but you are now doing manually what the audio was doing for free, and you are slower.

Sound as threat

The more interesting loss is the fear. The monsters in these games make noise when they notice you, and that noise arrives before you can see them. The gap between hearing and seeing is where the tension lives. Mute it and you get a series of surprises instead of a series of dreads, and surprises are much weaker.

The scariest sound in any of these games is a door opening in a room you already cleared.
A dark corridor with a door at the end
Nothing in this frame is dangerous. Something in the next room made a noise, which is why I stopped.

The silence between fights

One more thing that only became obvious with the sound back on: a lot of these maps have long quiet stretches. No music sting, no ambient drone, just footsteps and the hum of a lift. Those stretches are doing work too — they reset your attention so that the next noise lands.

Modern horror games tend to fill every second with sound design, and I wonder whether that is why so few of them make me stop in a doorway the way a twenty-year-old lift noise still does.


Verdict: play these with headphones, at night, and accept that you will be slightly worse at the game and much more absorbed in it.

← all posts